He believes that in order to fix this issue, the juvenile justice system need to be abolished and merged with the adult system. Secondly, we have the juvenile justice system, a court designed especially for minors and is generally thought to help rehabilitate the offender.
Youthfulness, Criminal Responsibility, and Sentencing Policy.
We need to provide adequate psychological support services to those who need them. Gault was detained by the police and held overnight without his parents being notified; he was required to appear at a juvenile court hearing the following day; a probation officer filed a pro forma petition alleging Gault was a delinquent minor in need of care and custody of the court; no witnesses were called; there was no sworn testimony or written record of the court proceedings; and Gault was not advised of his right to remain silent or to have an attorney.
Northwestern University Retrieved from http: It would also transition into a federal case, so it would be heard multiple times before a final resolution. Status offenders who did not comply with treatment ordered by the court could become criminal delinquents by virtue of being charged with criminal contempt of court.
I do agree with what Feld says about having a juvenile be granted his constitutional right to an attorney, jury trial and correct understanding to Miranda warnings.
Changes in laws do not necessarily translate into changes in practice. List of Pros of Judicial Activism 1. While this may work for adults, it is inappropriate for a youth. I still see it being problematic for the child to serve time in an adult facility.
Constitutional rights need to be awarded to every single person regardless of their age. American Journal of Public Health, 94 5 Many of these youth are waving their right to an attorney without the knowledge of what the consequences might be.
Judicial activism becomes a more profound subject for those who serve on the Supreme Court, as their rulings generally stand. Data on the latter three categories are not now collected nationally. First and foremost, juveniles must be accorded their constitutional rights.
Data were gathered during summer in Indianapolis and summer in St.Nov 08, · The major issue I intend to look at it is whether or not we should abolish the juvenile justice system. First, we will look at the position of keeping the current system, why it needs to stay in place, and why in the long run it.
Barry Feld makes a convincing argument for abolishing the juvenile justice system with his argument that it does not afford the juvenile his constitutional rights. He believes that in order to fix this issue, the juvenile justice system need to be abolished and merged with the adult system.
3 pages 7 Offenders Juvenile for Trial Right the of Analysis An words Examples, Essay System Justice Juvenile results total 53 US the in System Juvenile JV the of Implementation of Favor in Argument An words Massachusetts of State the in System Justice Juvenile the in Flaws The words In their discussion of the history of prevention and rehabilitation efforts in the United States, Agnew and Brezina indicate that _____ has been the major goal of the juvenile justice system from its inception in the s to the s.
The juvenile justice system has undergone significant modifications during the last 30 years. This section describes the system, focusing on structure and process features that relate to delinquency and status offense matters.
The juvenile justice system has undergone significant modifications during the last 30 years.
This section describes the system, focusing on structure and process features that relate to delinquency and status offense matters.Download